Salon
 
 
 
 
 

R E C E N T L Y

I love him incredibly, but I envision a life of hockey games, Super Bowl parties and chips and dip
(10/20/98)

If I write a salacious story in the first person, will readers assume it's about me?
(10/06/98)

How can I meet girls in odd clothing if I'm not a writer?
(09/22/98)

Why does my husband keep writing short stories about having affairs with younger women with pierced tongues?
(09/09/98)

How do I handle being the Antarctic stud?
(08/26/98)

- - - - - - - - - -

A L S O

About Garrison Keillor
Lovers and Writers archive

- - - - - - - - - -

C O L U M N I S T S

Sexpert Opinion
By Susie Bright
I'll write the book of love
(10/09/98)

The Reluctant Capitalist
By Heather Chaplin
The greatest gambling hall on earth
(10/23/98)

Left Hook
By Joe Conason
Head of Newt: Will Gingrich pay if Republicans blow the election?
(11/03/98)

Right On!
By David Horowitz
Hate crimes go both ways
(10/26/98)

Word by Word
By Anne Lamott
Mother rage: Theory and practice
(10/26/98)

On Television
By Joyce Millman
Praise the Lord and pass the remote
(10/26/98)

Ask Camille
By Camille Paglia
The dangers of the gay agenda
(10/28/98)

Under the Covers
By James Poniewozik
Politicians and pollsters, run! It's the attack of -- 60-foot Waitress Mom!
(11/03/98)

Let's Get This Straight
By Scott Rosenberg
The money's too good
(10/23/98)

Home Movies
By Charles Taylor
Camp Classic
(11/02/98)

Second Thoughts
By Sallie Tisdale
Why I love TV
(10/22/98)

 

Salon Columnists

- - - - - - - - - -


S A L O N
E M P O R I U M

FREE! 12-ounce bag of Salon Blend with a purchase of $30 or more. While supplies last.

  

D E A R _ M R . _B L U E
Garrison Keillor answers your questions about love and writing

 

Illustration by Zach Trenholm

 


Have I become one of those people William Bennett scorns as having no moral compass?


Dear Mr. Blue,

I'm a sensible sort who never expected to be in the middle of a Jerry Springer episode, but last year, somehow, my orbit collided with that of an old friend, a man who was living with another woman. They weren't sleeping together at the time (he said), though she had a child by him after a casual affair; his marriage had ended after years of infertility and he was desperate to have children. Things started to fall apart between him and his lover and then she got pregnant again.

So here we are, in love and him with two kids, avoiding the subject of what comes next. I know he loves his children, but he avoids being home whenever possible, using a heavy work schedule as a buffer. I tell myself he'd see more of his kids with me than he does now, but probably I am rationalizing. I divorced when my own children were small, and I know what pain they go through in a breakup.

I'm 44, he's 48. We both were cranky, sarcastic sorts with hidden hearts who softened and blossomed with each other. I have never been so happy. Am I an awful person for wanting to break up his home, unhappy though it may be? One of those people William Bennett scorns as having no moral compass? Is love, even a sweet and tender midlife love like this, a good enough reason to cause people pain? Or is love a good enough reason to stop causing yourself pain?

Philadelphia Philanderer

Dear Phil,

You have tumbled for a man whose life is something of a mess, and now your happiness is heavily mortgaged to his situation. Try to step back and take a clear look at where you are. Try not to be so available, so comforting, so wonderful. Be a little removed. And try to direct your attention (and his) away from how happy you two are and toward the fortunes of these two children. All the happy b.s. about wise breakups being good for children in the end --- you can skip that. If, as you say, this man has been avoiding home and his fatherly responsibilities, don't make excuses for him. I am sorry, Philadelphia, but he has got to face up to his situation and deal with it before he can make a life with you. He can't make you happy in the long term if he is a man who blows off his children.

Dear Mr. Blue,

Interesting women seek my friendship, but don't respond to my occasional romantic overtures. I fear I've been typecast as a "nice guy" or, worse, a "safe male." How can I generate a false dark side? I also can't plot my short stories. Is there a single solution to both problems?

Somewhere in Mississippi

Dear Somewhere,

Romantic overtures are always being dropped; barrooms are littered with shards of overtures. But if you're flirting with plausible women and they turn away, maybe you need to update your look. May as well start there. A man glances in the mirror in the morning and doesn't notice what's looking back at him: the waxed flattop, the beige-tinted aviator glasses, the goatee, which women read to mean that he's a right-wing nut. If you have a woman friend your age whose taste is adventurous but sure, ask her opinion. Try some new clothes. As for plotting short stories, the trick is to figure out where the middle is and start there, not the beginning.

Dear Mr. Blue,

I am 45 and married to a wonderful woman who is 17 years younger than I. I have three teenage children from an earlier marriage who share our household every other week, and everyone gets along swimmingly, teens and my wife, me and my ex, teens and her husband. I am deeply in love with my wife, and life couldn't be better. My wife wants us to have one child, maybe two, which I'm open to, but I'm worried about changing the status quo. I like babies, but I also know how much work it is to raise them and how children change your life. Any advice?

The Overpopulator

Dear O.P.,

You're having the normal trepidations a person ought to have before you beget a baby. Yes, having one does change your life, but life changes anyway, with or without one. You have a wonderful family to bring a new child into, and a wife who wants it, and a pool of baby sitters, and at 45 you'll be a terrific father. So accept your good fortune and go be fruitful.

Dear Mr. Blue,

I am a 25-year-old student with a full-time job and a live-in boyfriend of almost six years, and we are beginning to think about marriage and buying a house. I am steaming toward earning an MFA in poetry and am happy about how my writing is coming along.

In 1997 I was diagnosed with a neurological malformation with an uncertain prognosis. My symptoms are increasing, and it looks like I will need brain surgery.

Here's the thing: I need to take two more classes and then finish my thesis. I was going to finish in the fall of 1999, but I had to take a year off in '96, which really crushed me and ruined my self-confidence. If I have surgery this winter, I will be facing that again, along with three months of recuperation. But if I wait until May, I may damage my health. My doctor says that nothing is certain and I should have the surgery when I am ready to have it. What to do?

In Diagnosis Hell

Dear I.D.H.,

If I were your dad, I'd want you to have the surgery, once you got it clear in your mind what is involved and what might come of it. Your health has to come first. You have to march into the hospital and wage the good fight. Yes, it's a depressing prospect, to interrupt your life when it's going so well, but your academic year probably won't be a cheerful one with this crisis hanging over your head. Of course you can get a second opinion, but if you yourself are aware of your symptoms getting worse, then you should act right away.

Dear Mr. Blue,

My wife has been gone for two years now and I'm over her. It's the concept of marriage that I can't let go of. I feel as if I'm headed for a life of gold chains, cocaine, nightclubs and a three-week second marriage to Liz Taylor if I cut the cord. A steady wife would be a nice addition now that the nights are getting cold, but would one even be interested in me? Or should I just concentrate on bar chicks and relationships that vanish as quickly as the foam on the beer?

Floating

Dear Floating,

That life of gold chains and nightclubs only exists in Nevada and New Jersey and parts of Los Angeles. It's not to be found in the heartland, or in the South or the Northwest, so if the thought of transient relationships and inappropriate neckwear troubles you, get out of harm's way. But first get the divorce, which is the logical step after two years of separation. And then something else may happen. Perhaps a valiant woman walks into a room and a cloud of pheromones appears. She may not be a reliable source of heat or wish to become an addition to your life, but you can work that out between you.

Dear Mr. Blue,

I think you can tell a lot about a person by how he or she drives. And I'm deeply in love with a man who drives like an idiot. His other qualities are wonderful, but his driving is becoming a real problem and slowly eroding my respect for him. I don't want to dump him, and I don't want to die in a terrible crash. What am I to do?

White-knuckled in Boston

Dear Knuckles,

A man can change how he drives. Tell him it bothers you, and tell him he must either take driving lessons or drive as if he had. Don't give him this message casually. Soften him up for it with a period of coolness and distance, until he is moved to ask what is wrong, and then tell him. He'll think you're kidding. Tell him again. This is a basic expectation between human beings: that we not endanger each other.

N E X T+P A G E +| Every happy resolution generates some perverse negative reaction

 

 
 
Salon | Search | Archives | Contact Us | Table Talk | Ad Info

Arts & Entertainment | Books | Comics | Life | News | People
Politics | Sex | Tech & Business | Audio
The Free Software Project | The Movie Page
Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus

Copyright © 2000 Salon.com All rights reserved.