T A B L E_T A L K

Christmas and Chanukah: Who gets presents? How much do you spend? Discuss holiday giving in the Mothers area of Table Talk

___________________

Search BarnesandNoble.com for more about children and imagination
___________________

R E C E N T L Y

Making the list
By Polly Shulman
Your kids might not admit it, but there's a lot to be said for a present whose batteries don't run out and that you can take anywhere
(12/08/98)

Jews for Jesus
By Danny Miller
For my Holy Spirit-possessed sixth-grade teacher, it wasn't enough to sing the songs for our school's Christmas parade, we had to feel them
(12/07/98)

Second Thoughts: Twinns
By Sallie Tisdale
Double your pleasure, double your funn: Create a fantasy version of your child that will stay cute and small long after your kid leaves home and dumps you
(12/03/98)

Kids just want to have fun
By Anne Morrow Sampson
Why do the toys I bought my kids to improve their hand-eye coordination and spatial dexterity just sit in the closet?
(12/02/98)

The men's room
By Diane Lore
There's no rest for parents weary of making the decision whether to send their kids into public bathrooms
(12/01/98)

BROWSE THE MOTHERS WHO THINK FEATURE ARCHIVES

- - - - - - - - - -

Mamafesto
By Camille Peri
Why it's time
for Mothers Who Think

- - - - - - - - - -

IMAGINARY FRIEND | PAGE 1, 2
- - - - - - - - - -

You don't need to haul out Van Gogh to get into slippery terrain here. I once interviewed a famous novelist for a live radio program, starting with a fail-safe question: "How do you get ideas for your characters and what happens to them?" She described how her characters came to her. They whispered in her ear while she sat at the computer, or approached her while she washed the dishes. They told her what would happen next. Sometimes she wanted to quarrel with them. No, this is what we're going to do, she wanted to say. But usually, she acquiesced. They typically knew best.

That's how I remember the conversation, anyway. After the whispering in the ear part, I was blown right back into the suburban split-level where I grew up, when I glanced into my mother's bedroom to find her naked, alone and murmuring, "I see what you mean. They are all in on it."

I tried focusing on the sparkles of the author's suit, the clock indicating 45 seconds left in the interview, 44, 43. But I couldn't shake my panic as I brightly asked how she became a writer. I half expected her to start stripping right there, as my mother often did with no warning. I wanted to bolt out the studio door. Since then, I've heard similar descriptions of creating fiction by other writers. They talk to me.

Sure, I know what scientists and theorists would say about the differences among kids, artists and madmen. "Children have a very lush fantasy life. Most of that is a playful imagining. As children understand what's real and what isn't, that fades normally," Mark Bryan, co-author of "The Artist's Way at Work," once told me.

As for novelists talking to their characters, "It's a controlled fantasy," Bryan said. "Those voices are working toward a goal. There's an organizing ego. If I wake up and hear the voice of a killer in my head, I don't believe I'm channeling that killer. That voice is a culmination of my experiences. The question for a writer is how I continue to contact that voice, visit it again, drop down the creative well."

This sounds plausible. I've felt inspired moments when the writing seems to come through me, not from me. I can also be coldly intellectual, brandishing psychiatric jargon with the best of them. I can describe how schizophrenia is often caused by unhealthy enmeshment with a parent, how there's a difference between the realm of the unconscious, where imagination lies, and the realm of madness.

And yet.

And yet I became a journalist instead of a novelist because I'm afraid of characters I can't interview on the phone. I love storytelling, but I've reluctantly left invention to others. When Laurel talks about her sister, there are moments I drink in this beautiful, happy, imaginative child, but underneath my pride feel the unspeakable. Will she get the family disease? Or if she doesn't, will I, under the stress of parenting? Will the uninvited voices catch up with me?

I tell myself family abuse and violence, not genetics, were the catalyst for my mother's condition. Still, before deciding to get pregnant, I worried. In college, someone I thought was a friend heard my history and remarked, "I'd never have children with you. Bad genes." He recoiled a little at my snappy comeback -- "You weren't invited" -- but we both knew what he was saying. Given the possibility, I wasn't sure I would have had children with me.

I try to reassure myself by contrasting my husband and me to my mother's parents. They were straight out of an abnormal psychology textbook, producing my mother and a son who stuttered badly. Matriarch: Domineering, humorless, possibly prone to violence. Patriarch: Loving but weak. Accrues heart attacks like baseball cards. Rescues his daughter from challenge, whether she needs help or not. But I'm not like any of that. My child's household ain't perfect, but at least it's sane.

I compare the amount of time my mother and my child spend in their fantasies. My mother's life as a parent was one long psychotic episode with varying degrees of intensity. She never left the trance. My daughter's visits with her sister usually last a few joyful minutes. If those interludes are something akin to an altered state, they don't replace normal consciousness, they expand upon it. Sounds like creativity, right?

And I remind myself of their widely different attitudes. My mother never admitted she talked to oxygen atoms. When challenged, she denied anything was wrong with her. It was the people around her who were nuts. My daughter revels in her preschool magic, turning herself into a mom, a frog and a lawn mower within the space of five minutes.

We recently read a bedtime story about a girl named Ruthie and her imaginary friend, Jessica. They eat, sleep and pal around together until Ruthie meets a real girl named Jessica. The real child replaces the illusion. Ruthie and Jessica become best friends.

"Do you know someone like that?" I asked, expecting Laurel to name her best friend. "Yes!" she offered, giggling. "My sister!" My daughter's eyes were mischievous, as if she had been found out.

I might never be sure Laurel has escaped the family legacy. I might never be sure I have. My mother was not formally diagnosed with schizophrenia or any other brain disease. Technically speaking, I don't know what's wrong with her.

Maybe it's simply denial of the possibilities, but when I look at my exuberant child, I feel in my gut she will stay mentally well. As for my own sanity, I'll always have a flicker of doubt about what might happen tomorrow. I imagine myself a 100-year-old on my deathbed, surrounded by family, only then finally able to cheer, "I made it! I didn't crack up!"

Amid all this, something remarkable has happened. The child whose favorite game is pretend, who can imagine a truck out of a cookie and devise a new song every hour, is teaching me how to feel safe with invisible people, and even be their friends. I talked to an empty chair at an outdoor tea party this morning and saw the sister that Laurel loves. "What a sparkly morning!" my daughter said, dancing a little under lacy clouds. If this is madness, count me in.
SALON | Dec. 9, 1998

Andrea Cooper is a writer in North Carolina.

Become a Salon member. Click here.